REC

Liability in Car Crash Claims Explained

Who Is Liable in a Car Accident?

Most car crash claims begin with the other driver, but the driver is not always the only party who may be responsible. The vehicle owner, an employer, a government agency or a parts manufacturer may also play a role. Sorting out who may be legally responsible is an early task for a car accident attorney, because each party may have separate insurance.

The other driver

Negligence asks whether a driver failed to act with reasonable care. Common examples include speeding, distracted driving, impaired driving, following too closely and failing to yield. In many states, violating a traffic law can be evidence of negligence, and some states apply negligence per se. A traffic citation helps a claim, but it is not required to prove fault, and paying a ticket is treated differently from state to state. A car accident attorney will measure the driver's conduct against the traffic laws where the crash happened.

When someone else owns the car

If the driver borrowed the car, the owner's insurance policy often covers permissive drivers. An owner who lends a car to someone known to be unlicensed, impaired or reckless may face a negligent entrustment claim. Rental and leasing companies are a special case. A federal law known as the Graves Amendment generally protects them from liability https://jsbin.com/kokuvajuji for a renter's negligence, unless the company itself was negligent, such as by renting a car with known brake defects.

When the driver was working

When a driver is working within the scope of employment, the employer is generally responsible for the driver's negligence under respondeat superior. This can apply to delivery drivers, sales staff and others who drive for work. Rideshare crashes raise separate coverage questions, because the coverage that applies can depend on whether the app was on and whether a ride had been accepted. An auto accident lawyer will usually ask for the employer's policy along with the driver's own.

Other parties that may share fault

A broken traffic signal, a missing stop sign or a dangerous road defect may involve a government agency. Claims against cities, counties and states face special immunity rules and short notice deadlines, and those rules vary by state. When a defective tire, brake or airbag contributed to the crash or the injuries, the manufacturer can face a product liability claim. NHTSA's recall lookup shows open recalls by vehicle identification number. In some states, a bar that served a visibly intoxicated driver may face a dram shop claim.

Claims by passengers

Passengers who are hurt may have claims against one driver or both, including the driver of the car they were riding in. Coverage can come from the policy on the car the passenger rode in and from the other driver's policy, and in some cases from the passenger's own policy. Certain policies restrict claims between relatives who live in the same household, so the exact policy language matters.

Comparative negligence and multiple parties

Most states use comparative negligence, which can reduce a recovery by the injured person's share of fault, while a few jurisdictions still follow contributory negligence. States also differ in how fault is divided among several defendants. A car wreck lawyer reviews every possible party, since a single policy may not cover the whole loss. This is general information and not legal advice, and it cannot predict how a claim will turn out.